Sunday 04/21/2024 by phishnet


[We would like to thank Rob Mitchum for recapping last night's show. Rob is a science and music writer in Oak Park, IL. He tweets about Phish @phishcrit, other stuff @robmitchum, and he has undertaken the Sisyphean task of writing about every Phish show on its 25-year anniversary, which will take him until at least 2047…and counting.Thank you Rob! -Ed.]

For all the billions of dollars invested in audiovisual technology at the Las Vegas Sphere, the thing I was most curious about for these shows was decidedly less flashy: would the members of Phish stand in their usual spots? For 99.9% of Phish shows, they have set themselves up in the same way – four-across on a rectangular stage at one end of the venue. But the few times they deviated from this layout have almost always produced memorable experiences and unusual music, from the alternative stages of late-night festival sets and the inward-facing square of the Chilling Thrilling Sounds of the Haunted House costume to the flatbed truck in the round and the hourglass stage of MSG NYE stunts.

© 2024 Stephen Olker Photo
© 2024 Stephen Olker Photo

The influence of staging on the music makes a lot of sense, because Phish has always been a band heavily influenced by environmental choices and constraints. It’s why they’re more picky than most artists about what venues they book, why certain rooms and cities have attained can’t-miss status among fans over the years, for reasons that would seem mysterious to objective outsiders. Even when the band merely reshuffles what order they stand in (as they did in 1999, a year I’m about to become very familiar with), it can have a dramatic impact on their improvisational approach and communication.

So how exactly would Sphere, a venue unlike any built before it, force Phish to reconfigure both logistically and musically? That’s what I wanted to know. Amidst all the flashy imagery that leaked out of the U2 shows, the stage they played on looked weird as hell, a tiny little postage stamp (supposedly based, eye-rollingly, on Brian Eno’s turntable) with minimal lighting. One of the immediate observations from the Phish fan community was that the ever-growing mechanical skeleton of Chris Kuroda’s rig – an instrument as essential to the show as a Languedoc guitar – simply wasn’t going to work there. What else would have to change, and would it move Phish out of their comfort zone, for better or worse?

© 2024 Scott Marks
© 2024 Scott Marks

From what I could see through the tiny, imperfect window of social media posts, Thursday and Friday the band’s setup appeared relatively normal – they were all lined up as they have been since Mike moved to Fishman’s left in 2013. The lack of onstage amps and equipment and the expected strip-down of the lighting rig to just six vertical towers left the band feeling a little naked, and the amphitheater-style seating made it look from most people’s phones like the stage was unusually distant. But – ignoring the 256 million pixel elephant in the room – it seemed from afar like Phish just had to show up to work like they normally do.

But naturally, being there in person creates a very different impression. The walk in to the venue has all the set design immersion of a Disney ride, from the Space Mountain fonts and lighting to the lobby art installation and the bespoke ambient music wafting through the concourse. It’s by far the cleanest place I will ever see Phish, a world apart from the sticky-floored minor league hockey arenas and concrete exurban sheds that are their natural habitat.

© 2024 ZZYZX
© 2024 ZZYZX

And when you walk into the actual venue, what immediately leaps out is that the proportions are all off for what we expect from a Phish show. I’ve seen them in dozens of venues, and there’s a familiar reassurance in journeying to a strange city, navigating all the drama of getting to the show, and then walking in to see that same old stage, lit in soft blue light, patiently waiting for the band. The Sphere is not like that, at all. Even from a seat in the first balcony, which seems to have the best balance of stage and screen, the relative scale was disorienting with just the preshow washes of color, never mind the full blast visuals. It felt alien, dangerous, wrong…but unmistakably exciting. Constraints and possibilities abound.

I can only imagine that the band feels the same discombobulation walking out from the pixel-covered door at the bottom of the screen. And while I was pumped to see what they would do visually with that billion-dollar canvas, I was also keeping a close ear on whether this unusual environment nudged them into new sonic channels. It delivered one such moment right away, as they repeated the run’s nifty new trick of coming out to a pre-recorded jam – in tonight’s case, a Siket Disc-y haze over trip-hop drums – and layering the first chords of the opener over it.

Perhaps confronting the potential of this setup for severing the intimacy with fans, "Set Your Soul Free" immediately broke one of the rules they had joked about in the run-up to these shows by showing the band on the screen. Uncomfortable with the stadium-size close-ups of U2, the band and tech team landed on an effective compromise, with any shots of the musicians constantly distorted and filtered and manipulated. These visuals (which returned in a slightly different configuration for "46 Days") might not get the phone cameras out like some of the flashier set pieces, but they were a welcome reminder in that gargantuan space that there were four real humans down there making all the noise.

© 2024 Rob Mitchum
© 2024 Rob Mitchum

Forever masters of tension-release, tonight slow-rolled the real eye-popping scenery and opted for more “minimal” (an absurd use of the word) visualizations over the first three songs: colorful squiggles for SYSF, bubbles for "Tube," prismatic gem facets for "Stash." These flexible, non-scripted patterns seemed to line-up with the band being in a jammy mood right off the bat, with all three songs finding unusual tributaries. And it allowed for appreciation of the Sphere’s equally ambitious sound system, which was especially effective as Page and Trey deployed stranger and stranger effects in the thick of jams, synth and digital pedal squiggles and bloops darting out from unexpected corners of the room.

Just when I started to think the visuals had to hold back in order for the band to be fully free improvisationally, that theory was shattered by "Pillow Jets," the night’s first triumph. Moving slowly through a generative forest landscape that slowly morphed into an Avatar-like neon ecosystem, trees exploding with veins of light like a fireworks display, it was the first time the visuals lived up to the venue’s immersive promise. But more importantly, it inspired the band as much as the audience, transforming a song I previously found forgettable into one of the undisputed musical highlights. I came in with plenty of doubts that the screen imagery could organically influence and interact with the music with the same intensity and cohesion of Kuroda’s lights, but this performance settled it decisively.

© 2024 Rob Mitchum
© 2024 Rob Mitchum

That exquisite balance wasn’t always on display – I found myself missing the regular lights and the murky darkness of a normal Phish indoor show in "Stash" and "Steam," and at the end of the night, "Tweezer Reprise" didn’t explode as expected with Kuroda unable to work up the usual climactic frenzy. And there were points where the visuals almost made the music incidental. The presentation of "Taste" was a jaw-dropper, with Jim Pollock’s Live Phish CD art rotating like tapestries and hovering in astoundingly effective 3-D over the band, and the experience was so overwhelming and emotional I barely remember a note of the performance of one of my favorite Phish songs.

But the centerpiece of set two restored that balance through an ingenious combination of low and high tech. When I read that Abigail Rosen Holmes got her start as lighting director for Talking Heads’ Stop Making Sense shows, I was both excited and confused – that happens to be my favorite concert film of all time, but its deconstructed staging felt like the completely inverse of what these full-production Sphere shows promised. So it was a delight to see "Fuego" use one of my favorite setpieces from the movie, the front-lit silhouettes from “What A Day That Was,” updated and enlarged four decades later.

© 2024 Rob Mitchum
© 2024 Rob Mitchum

For the entire half-hour of "Fuego," a single motorized spotlight roved back and forth along a track at the front of the stage, throwing a shadow of one band member at a time behind them. Then this silhouette was multiplied and manipulated across the rest of the screen, melting and flickering to fit the night’s subtle “fire” theme. It was simple and adaptable enough to let the band stretch way out with a pointillist funk jam that frolicked around the room’s spatial audio, but compelling enough to not wear out its welcome over a long performance.

I kind of missed that organic touch as the rest of the night’s visuals returned to abstract patterns that tastefully flavored mid-size jams in "Golden Age" and "Twist" and a rare standalone "Hydrogen." Everything was still so damn technically impressive, but the accompaniment did feel more reactive compared to the cohesive audiovisual dialogues of "Pillow Jets" and "Fuego." No shots; by creating 50-some different visual experiences for this run, some were bound to work better than others. I took the opportunity to sit for a bit, and enjoyed the haptic sensations of Mike’s bass vibrating through the Sphere seats, like his pick was plucking my spine.

© 2024 Stephen Olker Photography
© 2024 Stephen Olker Photography

The late-show appearance of "Chalk Dust" may have constrained it somewhat from building upon its instant-classic performance in Mexico – it didn’t get nearly as dark and weird in the sci-fi bubble as it did on the beach, environmental influences be damned. But as starry constellations formed and burst apart above a fully-concentrated band, it finally clicked that this one-of-a-kind venue and its unusual proportions isn’t such foreign territory after all.

It turns out that Sphere, for all its groundbreaking tech, is actually of a piece with one of Phish’s favorite venue categories: arenas that look like spaceships. As children of the moon landing, the members of Phish are the right age to still see space as a limitless territory of awe and wonder, not commercial real estate for internet satellites and nuclear missiles. It’s no accident that so much Phish improvisation gets described with space-related terms, or that they cover the disco-jazz rearrangement of the classical theme from the greatest space movie of all time (and hopefully will tonight…”air” includes outer space, right?). Space is the place where Phish thrives, and Sphere, at its essence, is just a really, really big and really, really fancy planetarium.

© 2024 Scott Marks
© 2024 Scott Marks

So for all that the unusual logistics that these shows required – the months of technical and artistic preparation, the pre-written setlists, the lack of onstage amps and the plexiglass around Fishman – it still only took three nights for the Sphere to feel like home. Despite everything, the band still found its comfort zone, which may have meant that these were more “normal” Phish shows musically than part of me hoped for, but also that they would be terrific performances, even the morning after on headphones without all those pixels in my face.

In the end, they were still standing in the same place, experimenting and taking risks just like they’ve done for 41 years. Only the room has changed.

© 2024 Stephen Olker Photography
© 2024 Stephen Olker Photography

If you liked this blog post, one way you could "like" it is to make a donation to The Mockingbird Foundation, the sponsor of Support music education for children, and you just might change the world.


, comment by DuckDragon
DuckDragon Thanks for the great recap, Rob! I always love reading your essays and was hoping to somehow hear your perspective on the Sphere shows. I was at an event last night and only came home to stream the second set, but I absolutely loved it (I've so far seen two sets from the Sphere - Friday's first set and last night's second - and I'm hoping to catch up on the remainder on demand). Yes, the Fuego visuals were fantastic. I also thought the Chalkdust was pretty nifty - it obviously wasn't Mexico, but I liked how they wrapped up the Type I section completely before taking it Type II with a Mike's Song-style second jam. Anyway, huge FOMO about not being there in person, but it's mind-blowing even on the webcast, and I'm getting super excited to see D&C there in May.
, comment by 87easyed
87easyed Fantastic review!
, comment by CarrotEyes
CarrotEyes The connection made between the Sphere and planetariums seems very apt! Earlier today I was trying to put my finger on what it is about these shows that makes them feel so special to me, yet it wasn't until I read this review that I figured it out. I'm 15 years younger than Trey, but I grew up watching Star Trek: The Next Generation, reading books about astronomy and physics, and visiting various planetariums and science museums. Now that I'm thinking about it more, the "spherical" themes being explored through the visuals are a really cool complement to the kind of music made by Phish (which is all about chasing the elusive moment of discovery). I can't wait to see what happens tonight...
, comment by DevinB
DevinB I'm glad you noted that you found Taste "so overwhelming and emotional [you] barely remember a note of the performance" because I have been feeling that way throughout the run! Unlike most Phish shows, where I am keenly aware of the band's musical position at all times, I am finding the Sphere experience (ex-sphere-ience?) to be much whole holistic. The music and the visuals fuse into a single multisensory environment that resonates with me in completely different ways mentally and emotionally. I lose track of time, I lose track of instruments, I sometimes even lose track of where I am. I don't know enough about psychology to give any clinical terms or explanations, but 'altered consciousness' would probably be the best descriptor in our community's lexicon. Trey mentioned in an interview that the experience would be deeply psychedelic and he was absolutely right about that!
, comment by suzydrano
suzydrano Awesome recap Rob, you captured it all!
, comment by JeffrosBrain
JeffrosBrain Thanks for the recap. Only watched tonight’s show from my couch. I agree, at times I loved the visuals, like during Pillow jets, incredible. But then at other times I was missing the usual light show. Thanks again! By the way, I teach in Oak Park!
, comment by phootyjon
phootyjon Thank you, Rob. Very well written and precise, considering how complex things are getting.
, comment by Longhaireddan
Longhaireddan this is such a well written piece. it’s the first writing where i feel like i got a picture of the experience. awesome! feels like it doesn’t belong with the usual drivel here
, comment by golgischlem
golgischlem @Longhaireddan said:
this is such a well written piece. it’s the first writing where i feel like i got a picture of the experience. awesome! feels like it doesn’t belong with the usual drivel here
Because it doesn’t. Rob Mitchum was once / is? a professional music critic who wrote for Pitchfork, among others.

@Robmitchum Rob, please do another podcast with Steve Hyden, PLEASE.
, comment by BennyHa_Ha_Ha
BennyHa_Ha_Ha Excellent review, Rob! I've also been enjoying your essays/reviews of shows on their 25th anniversary. It's been a fun and enlightening experience to revisit them through your words; thank you for that.

I agree that the band truly settled in on Saturday night. In person I thought the sound was off a bit on Friday, but the LP audio of Set 1 actually sounds great. By Set 2 of Friday night they seemed to have worked out the sound issues in the venue. It could have just been the section I was in. The sound on Saturday was excellent.

When Phish is on, everything is easy for them, and that's the sense I had from the band on Saturday night. Total confidence, and even a bit of swagger. Pillow Jets was brilliant. It was a total dance fest in the venue with band and fans in sync from start to finish. What a blast!
, comment by 6silvermoonbeams
6silvermoonbeams I spend my quiet evenings and early AM mornings outside with my telescope. As I sat in the Sphere Sunday night, i kept thinking to myself, this is the ultimate planetarium. Hopefully they actually find a way to utilize it for that. Maybe put some Webb Telescope shows in there?

But the true star of the show was the sound quality. That was the best sounding concert I've ever heard. The seats had speakers built into them, so you could feel each of Mike's bass notes. The keys and guitars were sometimes coming from different places in the room. The guitar tone was perfect. It seems the big screen casts a shadow on the sound quality aspect to this venue. About half way through the show it became apparent that this is the ultimate venue. It is the best venue in the world for live music.
, comment by maction17
maction17 Lost in the too-many-to-count highlights is the 46 Days-- more specifically, what I viewed as a complete nod to the clone NYE gag. First, the colors were all consistent with their respective costumes that night. Secondly, the renderings on the screen had various and frequent clone aspects to them, and finally, what sealed it for me and made me smile: consistently, the image(s) of trey were lower than the other three. He was, in effect, finally brought down!
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Support & Mbird
Fun with Setlists
Check our Phish setlists and sideshow setlists!
Phish News
Subscribe to Phish-News for exclusive info while on tour! is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2024  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by Linode